Is the integration of urgent, emergent, inpatient and
care of patients with
acute medical conditions.
By Patti Papeleux
As the healthcare system is changing shape, and departments are realigning with the goal of increasing efficiency and care coordination, I hope that the big picture idea of the nature and purpose of healthcare does not get left behind. What is the value of human life? And how does this fit into the massive changes taking place in the organization and delivery of services?
At times, insurance companies and others try to estimate the value of human life for the purposes of cost/benefit discussions. Of course, this is an impossible task, as no one can assign a monetary value to a person’s life. Similarly, it is impossible to price out patients’ pain and emotional distress, or the ordeal suffered by their loved ones. But while I realize that businesses need to look at the bottom line, I hope that business decision makers realize that often the humanitarian perspective can benefit the bottom line. I hope that as the pressures mount and the Acute Care Continuum is forming, there is still time and a place for providers to ask, “What if this patient were my mother?”
For example, let’s look at the question of hospital readmissions. Hospitals are now being penalized for excessive readmissions. Medicare is going to penalize 2,217 hospitals for readmission, and these hospitals will pay about $280 million. And yet my father in law, who had stated that it was important for him to die at home with his loved ones, was shuttled multiple times in his final months between a skilled nursing facility (SNF) and a hospital, racking up a large number of hospital readmissions, and finally passing away in a SNF. Ironically and sadly, the readmission penalties established by the ACA would have worked to everyone’s benefit if he had simply been asked the appropriate questions. He would have refused the repeated hospital admissions, thus avoiding penalties for the hospital and also allowing himself to die in the environment he chose—his own home
If hospitals were able to design the optimum system for care, what would it look like? First, I think providers would be financially rewarded for quality of care as opposed to quantity, as has already been started by the ACA. Adverse safety events in the hospital can lead to longer stays and corrective treatments, as well as to deaths and readmissions. Adverse events, which can be consequences of short sighted cost savings measures, cost money! While designing environments to insure patient safety can entail costs, in the longer-term, doing so benefits both the business and the patient.
Patients’ preferences would also be taken into account for treatment planning. Like my father in law, patients’ choices may actually save money for the health care system. For example, sometimes less radiation could be better, and this might be the patient’s choice. But currently, with the system as chaotic and reactive as it is, there is little option to ask patients what they prefer. So patients are overtreated, both to their detriment, and to the detriment of the bottom line.
While CMS and the ACA can lead the way on this one with financial incentives, we must lead the way on ethics. EMTALA certainly is the right start when it comes to the ethics of treating sick people, but once patients are in the system, I hope that the dizzying speed of change does not make it more difficult for providers to take a long-term view and to concern themselves with the mission of healthcare and not just the business of healthcare. Within a longer term perspective, ethical, humanitarian treatment is compatible with sensible business practice.
Patti Papeleux is the Chief Operating Officer of MedAmerica. She has over 30 years of healthcare experience in both hospital and physician practice settings. Ms. Papeleux's areas of expertise are governance, risk/insurance, and healthcare operations. Her team includes a consulting team of diverse healthcare experts. She was instrumental in the development of MedAmerica Mutual Risk Retention Group, a professional liability company. Prior to joining MedAmerica, Ms. Papeleux was a risk manager for U.C. Davis Medical Center. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in chemistry from Colorado College and is masters prepared in business from California State University, Sacramento.
Trackback from Perspectives on the Acute Care Continuum
By Thomas Lukaszczyk, MD, FACEP
Over the years I have seen big changes in our practice of emergency medicine. I remember the first time I heard about an emergency physician down in the San Diego desert who treated his ED patients in the hallways, the... ...
Interesting and thoughful blog. If we are trained to "first do no harm" we have an obligation to ask the patient what they want. Clearly in this instance the patient would have had what he wanted and the hospital would have had what they wanted.
Click here to cancel reply.
Email (*) will only be visible to blog administrators
Remember my details
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail
Enter your email address:
By Kevin Kruse
While acute care hospitals are veterans in the fight to contain costs, healthcare reform is bringing greater focus to other aspects...
By Bruce Friedberg, MD
The northern San Diego region is growing rapidly, and last year, Palomar Health unveiled a state-of-the-art hospital to meet...
By Mike Harrington
About thirty years ago, I was an accountant for Arthur Young. One of my auditing clients was a young emergency...
By Ted Kloth, MD, FACEP
The time is coming when consolidation and transparency will reign supreme, and the effects are already being felt throughout...
By Theo Koury, MD, FACEP
Hospitals across the country are starting to feel the effects of healthcare reform. Beginning in fiscal year 2013 (September...
Re: Who Will Rescue Healthcare and Solve The EMR Debacle? We Need Another Steve Jobs
desfibriladoreszollaedplus.es I am so delighted I found your blog, I really found you by accident, while...
Re: Employee Engagement: A Critical Tool in the Age of Healthcare Reform
Être un sujet de fait inéluctable, la quantité de questions d'une dame porte couplé avec elle, va sur...
isaba.com I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first...
Re: All the World’s A Stage for this (Pay for) Performance
Acute care settings include but are not limited to: emergency department, intensive care, coronary care...
Re: Triage Out
The financial benefits to both the individual and the medical center from a triage out system are obvious...